Looking Back on Division, and Looking Forward to Unity.
From The Octographic Review (American Christian Review), JANUARY 3, 1892:
In the early part of our history as disciples it is a fact that discourses on “Oneness in Christ” were very common. But who preaches on that subject now? In view of the mischievous work of those who advocate humanisms in the worship and work of the church that subject is seldom discussed. It is among the themes of the past. That preacher would be a bold man, indeed, who would confront the religious world and say, “Allow me to show you what unity is, and how the Bible alone will produce unity.” Rather, such a man would be reckless. What then shall we do? Simply move onward. The Sand Creek Declaration is being adopted, and those who will not do right are purged out as old leaven. In course of a few years the Church of Christ will stand entirely separated from the Christian Church. Then there will be no more fellowship between them than there now is between the Church of Christ and any other branch of sectarianism. Hallelujah!
If Daniel Sommer only knew that he would look back at this moment, as do many other people in our movement, with lament and sadness.
The a capella Churches of Christ have been seperated from the Disciples of Christ and the Independent Christian Churches for 100 years now. Its time for us to heal with rift.
Our movement started out with the goal of restoring unity to Christianity through the rejection of creeds and the adoption of the Bible as the only guide to faith and practice. I think that was a worthy goal, and I believe it is still a worthy one. I think all sides have lost alot in the division.
When we split from the Disciples, we lost much of our heart for unity and for social justice. We we walked away, and finally when the Independents split away, the Disciples largely lost their call to return to primitive Christianity.
I think to be truly successful and complete, we need each other. Each group walked away and is now missing a vital part that the other has. We can learn from the Disciples and the Independents, and they can learn from us, as well.
So do something. Visit a congregation from another stream of the movement. Call the minister or elder on the other side and have coffee. Get to know those people who were supposedly “the enemy” and create some new allies.
I am going to do something. Sara and I have made a decision. Lord willing, I will quit my job next year, Fall 2007, and start full time going to school at Northwest Christian College - a school affilated with both the Disciples of Christ and the Independent Christian Churches, to work towards a degree in Theology. I will then persue admission to graduate school and study Church History and Theology.
Going to NCC, a school that has kept its ties to both the Disciples and the Independents, will put me smack dab in the middle of a bunch of people affiliated with the movement, but from different streams. Hopefully it will provide me with a good theological education, as well as provide me with strong credentials that I can use to work towards unity. My goal at this point is to earn a masters, teach, and work towards a doctorate, then teach some more and do some writing about unity and our movement. Its been a long discernment process, and I think that this is the direction he’s been leading me. I hope I’m right!
-Clarke
RSS feed for comments on this post. | TrackBack URI
June 9th, 2006 at 13:21
Just wondering: is anyone from the Disciples’ side making efforts toward unity?
And by “efforts,” I mean real, concrete efforts, along the lines of saying, “While I believe instrumental music is permissible, for the good of unity, I’m willing to give it up for my brothers.”
June 9th, 2006 at 13:40
Jeff:
I couldn’t tell you if there is anyone out there who said anything like that about music.
I have heard D. Newell Williams, who is a Disciples Historian, editor, and seminary president, state that he believes that the Disciples need to start putting more emphasis on baptism, though. He by him making that statement, I think we can believe that he puts more emphasis on it, which is an effort towards unity.
Also, there is the entire Disciples Heritage Fellowship, which is a group of conservative Disciples, as well as Independents, who want to emphasize the more conservative aspects of the movement.
I appreciate what you are asking, and I think it takes movement from both sides. Personally, I’m not going to pick up a guitar…but I’m not going to spit in their face if they don’t put the guitar down. I’m going to love them, and hope that they will love me as well.
-Clarke
June 9th, 2006 at 16:38
Hey Clarke,
Wow, I am inspired by your noble decision!!
I’m sure you know there are many difficulties ahead. Somehow we have to bring along those from our own circle as we reach across the divide. But the cause is right and I believe God will provide a way.
I will be right there beside you in the good fight (even though I am on the other side of the country!).
Alan
June 10th, 2006 at 2:20
I’m with Alan Clarke. I absolutely respect your willingness to hit this problem head on. The CoC needs more folks like you who are willing to stand up and say “hey, this isn’t right” Unity is what Christ wanted from His children. Good job.
June 10th, 2006 at 2:36
You might appreciate this….
http://mcgarveyice.blogspot.com/2006/06/stone-campbell-dialogue.html
June 12th, 2006 at 8:54
There is a lot of talk going on about unity, but not much discussion about Fellowship and what is/isn’t a fellowship issue. I think if we want unity we need to at least look at the issues that are truly out of bounds.
June 16th, 2006 at 8:41
Son of Adam:
I think the reason I haven’t talked about fellowship much is because unity and fellowship are synonymous to me.
As far as what is a fellowship issue to me: Baptism is the big theological one for me. The Lord’s Supper is also in there…I wouldn’t go to a church that didn’t partake of it weekly.
I could probably find more…I wouldn’t fellowship with the Eastern Orthodox churches because of veneration of icons, prayers to the saints, devotion to Mary…things of that nature.
JP:
I do appreciate that link very much.
Alan:
Thanks for the encouragement.
-Clarke